Best Cinnamon Rolls in New Haven

New Haven has 3 verified cinnamon roll spots on our map, every one checked for an actual roll, no sticky buns or imposters. Topping the list is Malby Artisan Bread and Pastries in Westville. The Farm Belly and Little Dandelion round out the front of the ranking.

Malby Artisan Bread and Pastries

⭐ 5.0

Westville · Bakery📍 912 Whalley Ave, New Haven

Cinnamon rolls on a short menu built around sourdough, focaccia and bagels.

View details →

The Farm Belly

⭐ 4.7

Fair Haven · Café📍 20 Grand Ave, New Haven

Cinnamon rolls come by pre-order tray of six from the weekly menu.

View details →

Little Dandelion

⭐ 4.6

Wooster Square · Café📍 208 Wooster St, New Haven

Cinnamon rolls come out of the oven behind the counter of a mom-and-pop coffee bar.

View details →