cinnamap
cinnamap.com
the ultimate map of the world's best swirls
← Back to map
925 cinnamon rolls
Updated today

Best Cinnamon Rolls in Lancaster

Something wrong?
Updated April 2026

Lancaster has 5 verified cinnamon roll spots on our map, every one checked for an actual roll, no sticky buns or imposters. Topping the list is Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop, a Classic American roll. Mr. Sticky's - Lancaster and Achenbach's Pastries round out the front of the ranking.

Ranked by Google rating weighted for review volume, plus press coverage and whether a bakery specializes in the roll. A 4.9 from a handful of reviews does not outrank a 4.8 from hundreds.

Bird in Hand · Bakery📍 542 Gibbons Rd, Bird in Hand

Amish country cinnamon rolls iced white, caramel or peanut butter

Roll Style
Classic American
View details →

Sticky bun stand whose iced cinnamon bun deserves equal billing

Roll Style
Classic American
View details →

Leola's Long John bakery, cinnamon buns by the baker's dozen

Roll Style
Classic American
View details →

Two-dollar iced cinnamon rolls at a Lititz scratch bakery cafe

Roll Style
Classic American
View details →

Keto, gluten-free cinnamon rolls at Central Market stand 69

Roll Style
Classic AmericanGluten-freeDairy-free
View details →
More city guides
Best Cinnamon Rolls in Philadelphia→Best Cinnamon Rolls in Pittsburgh→Best Cinnamon Rolls in New York City→Best Cinnamon Rolls in Denver→Best Cinnamon Rolls in San Diego→Best Cinnamon Rolls in Orlando→All guides→
Explore all 925 cinnamon rolls on the map
Every city, every spot. Filter by roll style, rating, and more.
Open the map →
@cinnamap|Guides|Trending|About|Add or Edit